Sunday, August 28, 2005

Unintended Consequences



The overturning of "Roe v. Wade" would have many unintended consequences beyond simply making if even more difficult, if not impossible, to obtain a safe, legal abortion in this country. By rejecting the core of "Roe v. Wade", that some issues are too private and personal to be subjected to governmental intrusion, a whole, ghastly can of worms is opened.

...Roe v. Wade is at the core of American jurisprudence, and its multiple strands of reasoning concerning marital privacy, medical privacy, bodily autonomy, psychological liberty and gender equality are all connected to myriad other cases concerning the rights of parents to rear their
children, the right to marry, the right use contraception, the right to have children, and the right torefuse unwanted medical treatment... - United States Senate Committee on the Judiciary: The Consequences of Roe v. Wade and Doe v. Bolton, June 23, 2005


It was in 1965 that state laws against contraception were struck down by the SCOTUS in "Griswold v. Connecticut" as being unconstitutional invasions of the privacy of married couples. This precedent was extended to unmarried persons only in 1971. The right to privacy established in "Griswold v. Connecticut" served as the basis for "Roe v. Wade".

This right to privacy extends to all areas of life, including the right to make medical decision...the right to decide whether or not to have children...the right of a terminally ill patient to refuse medical care...All are rooted in this same concept of privacy. Overturn "Roe v. Wade" and this entire fabric will unravel. A paternalistic and overbearing government steps in and makes these decisions, regardless of the wishes of the individual.

Should "Roe v. Wade" be overturned, women will no longer be the misstresses of their own lives and fates. Unable to make the determination as to whether they wish to get, or be, pregnant, the state will make that decision for them. They will once again be relegated to the status of second class citizens.